Get ready for a pitching showdown that’s flying under the radar—because while all eyes are on Munetaka Murakami’s arrival and the White Sox’s outfield battle, a fierce competition for the starting rotation is quietly heating up. But here’s where it gets controversial: with Shane Smith, Davis Martin, and Anthony Kay seemingly locked in, the real drama lies in the final two spots. And this is the part most people miss—the White Sox are treating this like an open audition, even if Erick Fedde’s reunion hints at securing the fourth spot. The early spring lineup? It’s only fueling the speculation.
Take Jonathan Cannon, for instance. After a rough 2025, he kicked off the Cactus League opener on Friday, proving no one’s spot is guaranteed. Chris Murphy, the November trade acquisition, might end up as a swingman, but he’s getting his shot on Saturday. Then there’s Sean Burke, last year’s Opening Day starter who’s now fighting for consistency—and his job—starting Sunday. With Will Venable hinting at ten pitchers in the mix (excluding top prospects like Noah Schultz, Hagen Smith, and Tanner McDougal), this isn’t just a competition—it’s a full-blown pitching free-for-all.
Here’s where it gets even more intriguing: David Sandlin, despite a shaky Triple-A debut in 2025, is still seen by the White Sox as a potential starter. Sure, his reliever role might’ve played a part in his struggles, but could he leapfrog straight to the majors? The team’s done it before, and a strong spring could seal the deal. Then there’s Duncan Davitt, the 26-year-old acquired from the Rays, who’s already on the 40-man roster. Even if he doesn’t crack Opening Day, he’s likely first in line for a call-up.
And let’s not forget Sean Newcomb. Originally signed as a bullpen boost, the White Sox are now floating the idea of him competing for a rotation spot. But here’s the bold question: is this a smart move, or are they better off keeping him in the bullpen where he’s thrived? His past as a starter with the Braves is tempting, but history suggests relief might be his sweet spot. What do you think—should they take the risk?
Other names to watch? Austin Voth, Shane Murphy, and Mike Vasil are all in the mix. As camp unfolds, this pitching battle is shaping up to be the most underrated storyline of the season. So, here’s the real question: Who’s going to step up and claim those final spots? Let’s hear your predictions in the comments—because this is one competition you won’t want to miss.
