The Bollywood star Hrithik Roshan, known for his role in the 2024 jingoistic blockbuster Fighter, has sparked a moment of reflection over the controversial film Dhurandhar. This Hindi cinema release delves into Karachi's Lyari gang wars, raising questions about its impact on geopolitical stereotypes. In a recent Instagram story, Roshan praised the film's cinematic craft, but also expressed a nuanced stance, stating, 'I may disagree with the politics of it' and questioning the responsibilities filmmakers hold as global citizens. This statement is particularly significant given the film's portrayal of Pakistan as a monolithic terrorist state, a trope that has become both commercially viable and politically convenient in Modi's India. The timing of Dhurandhar's release is especially sensitive, as relations between Pakistan and India were already strained due to the April 22 attack in India-occupied Kashmir's Pahalgam, which India blamed on Pakistan, a claim Pakistan has consistently rejected. The attack was claimed by the little-known group The Resistance Front (TRF). Against this backdrop, another film reinforcing stereotypes of Pakistani violence could be seen as more than just creative expression; it could be a catalyst for long-simmering tensions. Roshan's statement on Dhurandhar's politics and responsibilities as a filmmaker is thought-provoking, especially considering the industry's history of leaning into anti-Pakistan and anti-Muslim tropes in films like The Kashmir Files, Mission Majnu, and The Kerala Story. These films have garnered mixed reactions, with right-wing applause and condemnation from those weary of the industry's propaganda. The question remains: Is Roshan's musings on Dhurandhar a sign of genuine critical reflection or a diplomatic balancing act to avoid controversy? The industry's impact on global perceptions and the consequences of dehumanizing narratives in real-world contexts cannot be overlooked. As Roshan navigates this complex terrain, his stance on Dhurandhar and the responsibilities of filmmakers will be crucial in shaping his future creative choices and their impact on audiences worldwide.
